Computational Result Review Process - Revision history

Maechlin at 21:49, 4 September 2015

2015-09-04T21:49:41Z

Maechlin: /* NERC Mode */

2015-06-01T21:43:42Z

NERC Mode

Maechlin: /* State 4 - Publishable */

2015-06-01T21:42:53Z

State 4 - Publishable

Maechlin: /* State 4 - Publishable */

2015-06-01T21:41:34Z

State 4 - Publishable

Maechlin at 21:41, 1 June 2015

2015-06-01T21:41:20Z

Maechlin at 21:37, 1 June 2015

2015-06-01T21:37:15Z

Maechlin at 20:55, 27 May 2015

2015-05-27T20:55:10Z

Maechlin at 20:56, 20 May 2015

2015-05-20T20:56:03Z

Maechlin: /* Reviewed */

2015-05-20T18:32:37Z

Reviewed

Maechlin: /* Reviewed */

2015-05-20T18:16:17Z

Reviewed

← Older revision		Revision as of 21:49, 4 September 2015
Line 40:		Line 40:
	*[[CME Project]]		*[[CME Project]]
	*[[CyberShake Project]]		*[[CyberShake Project]]
		+	*[[CyberShake Review Process]]

@@ Line 31: / Line 31: @@
 == NERC Mode ==
-* Servable
+* Dataset Serving
-* Technical Quality
+* Dataset of Technical Quality
-* Publication Quality
+* Dataset of Publication Quality
 [[Image:Stages of Publication.png|right|250px]]

@@ Line 28: / Line 28: @@
 == State 4 - Publishable ==
 Ready for use by external researchers.
 [[Image:Stages of Publication.png|right|250px]]

@@ Line 29: / Line 29: @@
 Ready for use by external researchers.
-[[Image:File:Stages of Publication.png|right|250px]]
+[[Image:Stages of Publication.png|right|250px]]
 == Related Entries ==
 *[[CME Project]]
 *[[CyberShake Project]]

@@ Line 29: / Line 29: @@
 Ready for use by external researchers.
-[[Image:SCEC_NSF-USGS-words_logom.png|left|150px]]
+[[Image:File:Stages of Publication.png|right|250px]]
 == Related Entries ==
 *[[CME Project]]
 *[[CyberShake Project]]

@@ Line 4: / Line 4: @@
 To begin, we define the data set under consideration. For example, a hazard curve that is part of a study, might be considered, even if the full study is not complete. A single hazard curve could be in one state, while full study can be in another state.
-== Started ==
+== State 1 - Started ==
 Data set calculations have begun.
-== Preliminary ==
+== State 2 - Preliminary ==
 The data set calculations are completed, and complete results are believed to exist.
-== Reviewed ==
+== State 3 - Reviewed ==
 Data-set specific, standardized, defined, checks ready for use internal researchers.
@@ Line 24: / Line 24: @@
 * Calculate ratio maps between new results and 14.2
-== Publishable ==
+== State 4 - Publishable ==
 Ready for use by external researchers.

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
-We define three states through which large scale computational results increasing in confidence.
+We define various states through which large scale computational results are migrated. Each stage indicates and increasing level of confidence in the correctness of the results.
 == Define Data Set ==
-Define which data set under consideration. For example, a hazard curve that is part of a study, might be considered complete, even if the full study is not complete.
+To begin, we define the data set under consideration. For example, a hazard curve that is part of a study, might be considered, even if the full study is not complete. A single hazard curve could be in one state, while full study can be in another state.
 == Preliminary ==
-Just created but complete
+The data set calculations are completed, and complete results are believed to exist.
 == Reviewed ==
-Data-set specific, standardized, defined, checks ready for use internal researchers. For example, for a hazard curve, review checks might include:
+Data-set specific, standardized, defined, checks ready for use internal researchers.
-* no Nan
 * No amplitudes beyond 5g
-* all rupture variations have amplitudes for all components
+* All rupture variations have amplitudes for all components
-At study level:
+When we consider the full study as the data set under consideration, we might define the following rules:
-* all hazard curves reviewed state, plus
+* all component hazard curves are in the reviewed state, plus
-* new hazard maps
+* Calculate new hazard maps
-* ratio maps between new results and 14.2
+* Calculate ratio maps between new results and 14.2
 == Publishable ==