0.2 sec geometric mean hazard map, all sites, marked
0.2 sec 2008 NGA basemap
0.5 sec geometric mean
0.5 sec geometric mean hazard map, all sites
0.5 sec geometric mean hazard map, all sites, marked
0.2 sec 2008 NGA basemap
1 sec geometric mean
1 sec geometric mean hazard map, all sites
1 sec geometric mean hazard map, all sites, marked
0.2 sec 2008 NGA basemap
2 sec geometric mean
2 sec geometric mean hazard map, all sites
2 sec geometric mean hazard map, all sites, marked
3 sec geometric mean
3 sec geometric mean hazard map, all sites
3 sec geometric mean hazard map, all sites, marked
5 sec geometric mean
5 sec geometric mean hazard map, all sites
5 sec geometric mean hazard map, all sites, marked
10 sec geometric mean
10 sec geometric mean hazard map, all sites
10 sec geometric mean hazard map, all sites, marked
Comparison Maps
2 sec
3 sec
5 sec
10 sec
Difference
Study 15.12 vs Study 15.4, 2 sec geometric mean, difference map. Warm colors are higher Study 15.12.
Study 15.12 vs Study 15.4, 3 sec geometric mean, difference map. Warm colors are higher Study 15.12.
Study 15.12 vs Study 15.4, 5 sec geometric mean, difference map. Warm colors are higher Study 15.12.
Study 15.12 vs Study 15.4, 10 sec geometric mean, difference map. Warm colors are higher Study 15.12.
Ratio
Study 15.12 vs Study 15.4, 2 sec geometric mean, ratio map. Warm colors are higher Study 15.12.
Study 15.12 vs Study 15.4, 3 sec geometric mean, ratio map. Warm colors are higher Study 15.12.
Study 15.12 vs Study 15.4, 5 sec geometric mean, ratio map. Warm colors are higher Study 15.12.
Study 15.12 vs Study 15.4, 10 sec geometric mean, ratio map. Warm colors are higher Study 15.12.
Comparison with NGA results
We would expect the stochastic results to show reasonably good agreement with the deterministic results, but they do not. Here are some data products to investigate this. We've chosen 3 sites with large differences (MRVY, s028, LAPD) and 2 we're familiar with (PAS, USC).
NGA-2 curve comparisons
We replotted the curves using NGA-2s (instead of NGA-1) for comparison, and RotD50.
Site
0.5 sec
0.2 sec
USC
PAS
MRVY
s028
LAPD
Changing RVSIG
We reran PAS using rvsig1 = 0.1; comparison curves are below.
